Jacquelyn Truxaw
March 27, 2011
Assessment Measures Used at Good Shepherd Catholic School… Proud to connect direct standardized testing with reading material from this module! ☺
When reading Early Reading Assessment: A Guiding Tool for Instruction, the Iowa Test of Basic Skills, or ITBS, is used in a variety of assessment measures for reading. ITBS uses the reading areas of phonemic awareness, decoding, and reading comprehension to assess skills. In doing so, ITBS assesses a variety of reading areas to help student access skills, strategies, and content from the general education curriculum.
Module 4: Case Studies
Level A – Case 1
I selected the reading strategy for Luke based on his academic behaviors displayed in class, and goals generated from his falling phonemic awareness skills. Independent Practice provides Luke with opportunities to receive immediate feedback. One form of independent practice is self-correcting material, which immediately informs him of the correct answer. Luke’s skills in phonemic awareness are falling, and he is displaying frustration towards peers to gain attention during this instructional period. Specifically, Luke would be provided with a variety of self-correcting materials during learning centers or instructional periods, and blend phonemes together when looking at a picture. The flap would display the letter that matches the sounds, which helps reinforce the phonemes within words. Matching cards, for example, would verify the mastery of sounds and skills Luke needs to master. An important integration of technology through reading games on the computer would engage Luke and reinforce the phonological skills he struggles with.
Independent Practice allows Luke to learn to read by practicing his reading skills in an enjoyable, independent format. The preparation for independent activities is sometimes time consuming, but scaffold the skills needed to be practiced, and supplement the teacher instruction.
Level A – Case 2
The Model-Lead-Test approach to teaching is used to provide and demonstrate frequent opportunities for students to develop and practice new skills, reinforcing important reading skills with direct teacher guidance. The Model-Lead-Test approach includes the following three phases: (1.) Model Phase, (2.) Lead Phase, and (3.) Test Phase. The Model Phase is the teacher demonstration and modeling of expected skill(s). The Lead Phase enables the students to practice the skill and lead them towards automatically responding as a group. The Test Phase measures the student’s ability to perform the skill correctly and automatically. This approach provides an automatic response for Tawanna, which supports her learning needs.
The Model-Lead-Test approach supports Tawanna in reading difficulties by explicitly instructing the skills, and incorporates a repetition of the reading skills with direct teacher supervision. I would point to one word and say it aloud. Tawanna would repeat the word. Then I would say, “_________ rhymes with ____________.” She would repeat that sentence. “What sound do both words make?” I would ask the group of students to say the matching sounds as I point to the letters. In doing so, I would immediately observe and measure the understanding of reading skills.
Independent Practice activities engage learners by allowing them to practice and apply the skills previously taught. There are many forms of independent practice activities such as learning centers independent reading, technology assisted learning, and self-correcting materials. Some important tips for independent practice activities are establish a classroom environment that hones on the reading development and interests of the students; provide a planned and established classroom management schedule for independent practice activities such as learning centers; set-up the materials and resources for the reading period accordingly; engage all learners with various reading and writing activities, and; include time to monitor student progress in skills. A key support system for Independent Practice activities is parent involvement, both at home and school. Informing parents and organizing parents to volunteer at school helps encourage students, including Tawanna, to achieve her goals. Implementing rhyming books and games would also address the skills by offering a fun and enjoyable way to practice skills.
Level A – Case 3
Peer tutoring is a common and effective strategy used at Good Shepherd Catholic School because the children work on selected skills in a structured and active manner. Peer tutoring can be used with the whole class or cross-age, such as fourth grade students tutoring first grade students on reading aloud high frequency words and reading the words aloud using a reciprocal teaching method. The teacher carefully pairs students based on instructional responses and observation, whereby the student with higher performance in sight words teaches, reinforces, encourages and supports a learner with lower performance. Students can work in pairs with word sheets, flash cards, or teacher-made sheets to practice new sight words. In addition, the students review previously learned sight words and include the words in short, comprehensive sentences.
Repeated reading’s goal is to increase reading fluency by developing automatic word recognition skills. In doing so, repeated reading of familiar text leads to gains in comprehension skills, and reading and accuracy rates. Repeated reading has a variety of approaches such as partner reading, group repeated reading, word wall, flash cards, and reader’s theater. Word wall activities, such as using the words in a sentence or chanting the words, are engaging and an opportunity for the students to connect and actively participate in their learning experience of sight words. Since the teacher in kindergarten recorded the mastery of words as a concern, these activities would involve more leaning intelligences, engaging the learner holistically. Observing Greg’s mastery of sight words with the incorporating of chanting the words and using them in sentences would help him to meet his instructional goal.
Independent practice, or activities to practice skills previously instructed, engage and require students to interact with print. Since Greg struggles to state a sight word automatically, a computer-assisted instruction (CAI) would provide Greg with the opportunity to hear and see sight words on the computer screen, and respond. Extending the independent practice at home would allow him ample practice opportunities and immediate feedback.
Peer tutoring would be an excellent and beneficial approach for Greg, identifying, practicing, and reinforcing his behavioral and academic needs. Since Greg was beginning to display frustrated behavior, peer tutoring creates a structured environment for the tutor to guide the tutee, and provide immediate, corrective feedback for incorrect responses and positive reinforcement for correct responses.
I have a teacher-made list of sight words, based on the Dolch list of sight words and sight word lists made by various teachers, ranging in sight words from grade one to grade three. I created this list to assess my students on this standard. Since I have readers from first grade to fourth grade, I try to effectively challenge all learners. In doing so, the list shown at the end of this blog demonstrates this personalized list for my students.
Level A – Case 4
Graphic organizers are simple and purposely organized diagrams to support all students in organizing and recalling important elements from stories. They map the events of the story, identify the key components, identify knowledge before, during, and after, etc. to further enhance the reading development and comprehension levels of students. They are effective tools for students at-risk because they are explicit and provide a framework for systematically reading a text. They are beneficial for students with comprehension difficulties, like Orlando, because it breaks the story into parts, making it comprehensive and explicit.
Repeated reading teaches students to read fluently, helping students develop automatic word recognition skills. Partner reading would benefit Orlando because it allows the higher-level reader to model fluency, further guiding him towards the recognition of key reading components and elements, as provided by the teacher in his goals.
Comprehension strategies are the techniques a proficient reader uses to gain meaning of text. These strategies require purposeful planning and systematic guidance for students, attending the story elements in a thoughtful manner, and integrating background information, vocabulary lessons, and skill-building during reviews and practices. A beneficial comprehension strategy for Orlando would be Tried and True Comprehension Strategies. Tried and True Comprehension Strategies implement predicting, summarizing, retelling, rereading, and questioning strategies. Using direct, explicit instruction, I would employ these comprehension strategies for Orlando. Direct instruction would provide the baseline knowledge of comprehension strategies, and I would incorporate these strategies because they activate his knowledge about the content. Using an early reading level would further support Orlando with the skills to identify the main idea and provide opportunities for him to employ the strategies. By fully engaging Orlando with the implementation of Comprehension Strategies, his reading strategies become meaningful and purposeful.
I would have Orlando write the main events in sequential order for the “The Three Little Pigs” in the story map shown below. This story map uses vocabulary of sequential order, and could be incorporated into a unit. The story map (or graphic organizer) allows him to employ the tools already given (teacher’s explicit instruction and/or modeling). It also organizes the reading material, giving him the key components of the story (characters and setting), further supporting the retell of the story.
Description of the content placed within graphic organizer of “The Three Little Pigs” is provided below.
First, the Momma Pig tells her three little pigs that they must move
out and build their own house, but to watch out for the wolf.
Next, the three little pigs each build their own house made out of
straws, wood, and bricks.
Then the wolf came and blew down the house of straws and wood, but could not blow down the house of bricks.
After, the wolf became so angry he attempts to trick the little pig by
telling them to meet him at the turnip fields, the apple tree, and at
the fair. The little pig was so smart that he was able to run away
from the wolf.
Finally, the world was tired of the pigs witty ways so he leaps onto
the pig’s roof and threw himself down the chimney. He fell right into a pot of soup and was cooked. That night, the little pig had wolf soup for supper.
Level A – Case 5
Graphic organizers are diagrams that organize story elements to enhance reading comprehension skills in an organized and identifiable manner. Graphic organizers assist student learning for student to organize and recall elements in stories. A literary web, for example, would help Teresa understand the story in terms of both the whole and its part. Sine she has difficulty sequencing the middle of a story, the literary web would break apart the difficult components of the middle of the story. A story map for sequencing would help Teresa represent the sequence of events within the story using key words or pictures for representation. Teaching her the metacognitive tools to identify in the story provides and explicit instruction on attending to story elements and what they entail. Teresa’s struggle to identify the middle of the story would be reinforced with a mental picture of the story with the use of story mapping, further attending to all story elements.
The materials needed to prepare or gather in advance in order to teach this activity to Teresa are:
I. Obtain a below-Reading Level book to easily identify the beginning, middle, and end of the story.
II. Create a literary web with images for Teresa to identify key elements on poster paper (for teacher easel).
III. Create a story map for sequencing using the words beginning, middle, and end to represent the key elements of the story. (Have pre-made story images to illustrate the story parts, and further scaffold her towards recalling the three sequenced events.)
Level B – Case 1
There are many independent practice activities I would employ for Raymond inside and outside the classroom. These strategies would be an opportunity for Raymond to readily employ and demonstrate the correct strategies with identifying rhyming words and lower case letters, and comprehending the sequence and main idea(s) of stories. Independent practice strategies include games and interactive learning styles, such as simulation activities, independent reading, and self-correcting puzzles. These games are motivational and readily available and accessible for students to practice skills he or she struggles with.
Comprehension strategies are the techniques a provide students with the metacognitive skills that they can use to gain meaning from a passage or text read aloud or silently. These strategies employ students with the systematic skills and tools for reading comprehension. Raymond struggles to identify the main idea(s) and sequence all of the events in a story. Thus, the implementation of comprehension strategies would set a purpose, activating his knowledge about the text prior, during, and after reading a text or passage. Predicting, Summarizing, Retelling, Rereading, and Questioning are strategies I would teach Raymond the strategies to employ as, eventually, an independent and comprehensive reader.
Independent practice strategies are easily implemented at home for students with reading difficulties, such as Raymond. For Raymond to achieve the goal about the sequencing of order of events in the story could be instructed and modeled, using key comprehensive words: predicting, summarizing, retelling, rereading, and questioning. After at least 4-5 lessons in class of using this vocabulary, I would incorporate a guided activity, followed by an independent practice activity with flaps and windows to self-check the correct answers. Raymond would also make a book at home for a project, as will the class, to demonstrate the understanding that print conveys meaning through a sequential story guide that has a beginning, middle, and ending representation picture.
Level B – Case 2
I would address Amanda’s goals in the following sequential order:
1. Given a letter or letter combination, Amanda will say the corresponding sound
2. Given a CVC (consonant-vowel-consonant) word prompt, Amanda will be able to say the word “slowly” (sounding it out) and then say it “fast” (reading as a whole word)
3. Shown sight words, Amanda will state the word automatically
4. Given a brief reading passage on her instructional level, Amanda will read the passage and be able to retell the main ideas
5. After listening to a story, Amanda will recall three or four sequenced events
Model-Lead-Test approach to teaching would help Amanda match the letter with the corresponding sound. The teacher verbally models the skill by pointing to a letter on a card, then say how that latter makes a certain sound. The teacher questions Amanda what sound the letter makes, followed by the student and teacher responding together. To test Amanda, the teacher points to the letter, and she says the matching sound. Using the model, lead, and test phases, Amanda receives more detailed practice. In addition, the teacher is able to monitor her performance immediately and accurately.
Amanda’s parents would be involved in a consistent and collaborative manner. If possible, they would volunteer once a week during learning centers to positively interact and encourage her skills and the skills of her peers. This presence in the classroom would also reinforce positive attention and involvement of her learning experience, displaying the importance of learning skills. Using word cards within the classroom and home, Amanda and a parent/teacher would play a game called “Say it Slow. Say it Fast.” “Say it Slow. Say it Fast.” is an activity where one person says the word on the card slowly as the partner says it fast. Having a sound box whiteboard to support this learning game would make it more engaging and fun. This activity would also be an effective activity with a peer tutor.
Level C – Case 1
Jeff’s goals are:
1. Given a letter or letter combination, Jeff will say the corresponding sound
2. After listening to a story, Jeff will recount through retelling details, events, and ideas.
3. Jeff will use imagery to create a mental picture of the story.
4. Jeff will use book language while pretending to read.
Given a letter or letter combination, Jeff will say the corresponding sound
The Model-Lead-Test approach to instruction requires explicit, systematic instruction for Jeff to say the corresponding sound correctly and automatically. I would point to the letter and say the sound of it. Then I would point to the letter on a word card, stating the sound of this letter. Asking what sound this letter makes, the student responds with me, saying the correct sound. I would then point to the letter (test phase), checking where the students can say the matching sound. Demonstrating the correct sound repetitively provides frequent opportunities for Jeff to practice the new skill with direct teacher supervision. This immediate feedback benefits his correct approach to saying the sound of the letter identified.
After listening to a story, Jeff will recount through retelling details, events, and ideas.
The second goal requires the implementation of comprehension strategies, which would include a systematic approach to introducing these skills for Jeff during the reading process. Using who, what, when, where, and how questions of text would support Jeff, and model, guide, and support his comprehensive understanding.
Jeff will use imagery to create a mental picture of the story.
Graphic organizers would be used to help Jeff identify and answer questions about story elements, such as characters, settings, and events. Since Jeff enjoys art and hands-on activities, graphic organizers would employ key reading skills for him use on attending to story elements in order to make this connection with the text.
Jeff will use book language while pretending to read.
The first strategy for this goal would be repeated reading because it would allow Jeff to practice focusing on comprehension skills rather than decoding. The passages would be short and interesting, and comprehension would be emphasized with utmost importance. I would implement partner reading and group repeated reading, where the students would echo each line modeled by the teacher. This strategy would be used repeatedly, so that students can correctly say new words with plenty of time and opportunity.
The second strategy implemented for this goal would be independent practice. Independent practice activities help with retention of information and interaction with reading materials. There are different types of independent practice, such as self-correcting materials, computer-assisted instruction, games, and independent reading. Computer-Assisted Instruction (CAI) would provide Jeff with the visual and hands-on supplement to traditional, teacher-led instruction. He has been actively participating, but struggling to comprehend and practice reading skills effectively. CAI would effectively document the student performance, and provide further information to gauge comprehension of the materials prior to the meeting with the school psychologist and reading specialist in three weeks.
The Collaborative Strategic Reading (CSR) program would be an inclusive, procedural practice for Jeff’s teacher to implement at his school because it supports students’ comprehension skills and documents student progress. Strategies, such as preview, click and clunk, get the gist, and wrap up, maximize student engagement, and fuse cooperative learning with reading strategies. Jeff actively participates in class, and the assigning of roles through cooperative learning would encourage his behavioral strengths, and better address the reading difficulties he displays.
Level C – Case 2
Tyra’s goals are:
1. Shown sight words, Tyra will state the word automatically.
2. Given a letter or letters, Tyra will identify and say the corresponding sound.
3. Tyra will read aloud with accuracy and comprehension from any text that is designed for first grade.
4. Tyra will self-correct identified words by using cues in the word or context clues.
Shown sight words, Tyra will state the word automatically.
Creating a word wall for sight words by creating repeated reading activities would encourage Tyra to refer to it, and connect the words with meaning. I would have my students chant the words with movements to say the words. This opportunity would allow my students to state the word in the chants, and engage the whole body in a learning experience. In doing so, Tyra would not be distracted, rather fully engaged.
Given a letter or letters, Tyra will identify and say the corresponding sound.
Model-Lead-Test approach would help Tyra say the corresponding sound through repetition, model, and practice. This approach tests her ability to identify the correct sound, and provide automatic feedback from the teacher. This approach would be taught during learning centers, which would further support her learning needs because it is small group instructional methods. The learning centers would employ individualized reading activities for her to practice and master. In addition, partner grouping and/or small grouping would establish a learning environment of engaged learners.
Tyra will read aloud with accuracy and comprehension from any text that is designed for first grade. Using a reciprocal teaching method, I would use classwide peer tutoring to pair my high performers and low performers to read aloud. Partner reading would be the approach implemented for Tyra, allowing the higher reader to act as a model for the lower reader. Since Tyra enjoys working in small groups, partner reading would be a rewarding task for her, where she would be increasing her reading fluency and being modeled the pace, expression, and tone. This would teach my students to become strategic readers by connecting what they know to what they are reading in a focused and individualized manner.
Tyra will self-correct identified words by using cues in the word or context clues.
Tyra would use independent practice games to self-correct her misunderstandings in a format that better maintains her interest levels. Using independent practice activities, such as the self-correcting materials, Tyra would help her to foster the correct form of using cues in the word of context clues with immediate feedback of the correct answer.
Project I Can Read (or ICARE) would help Tyra with learning her reading skills during small group instruction. Incorporating modeling, guided practice, and independent practice within ICARE would allow her to read aloud into the iPod and listen to herself as she would replay it to self-evaluate herself using a rubric. This individualized and interactive approach to practicing and applying reading skills would support Tyra with her accuracy and automatic word recognition of sight words. http://projecticanread.com/ provided information above about Project I Can Read.
The High Frequency Word List Assessment below is the teacher sheet I use to evaluate my students throughout the school year.
_______________________’s High Frequency Word List Assessment
This assessment evaluates the correct pronunciation of high frequency words read aloud.
Directions: Highlight words correctly pronounced. Circle a word incorrectly pronounced, write the date beside it, and read the word together. STOP the assessment when a word is circled.
1 I a be run as
2 no by he at fly
3 we up it so old red
4 an is had will let new
5 to in be how am play
6 or his all but me into
7 yes day us if ran eat
8 get that which out say must
9 about like the and go over
10 my one you off are has
11 on each here big your of
12 not can for too what fast
13 who once them find have ask
14 then little do said friend where
15 away two does were did from
16 went look see every this some
17 many want come people oh could
18 always know because stop
19 she walk would happy saw him
20 they today was water love three
21 best very there says nice why
22 girl boy with again when done
23 their laugh only sure put seven
24 through though they’re somewhere help its
25 pull make family right favorite make
26 used to a lot during other shoe her
27 enough eight heard these thing thank
28 beautiful four should buy just keep
29 after show give gone bear ride
30 none much great build cover nothing
31 anyone gave busy hurray clothes move
32 special berry break guess five woman
33 under trouble pretty lived first laughter
34 down blue jump white soon well
35 take any funny now going open
36 think round our please good don’t
37 goes sit found upon wish pull
38 both call sleep been before made
39 sing read write cold green around
40 far draw clean grow shall together
41 own small hurt done better light
42 never six drink bring kind warm
43 carry myself start pick work wash